Problem
There are several tips and articles on the internet that discuss how to split a delimited list into multiple rows. This tip shows two approaches to this problem a T-SQL function and a CLR function.
Solution
The following examples show two different approaches to splitting a delimited list into multiple rows. Both approaches return the same result set, but this tip will show the different techniques to deploy the functions.
T-SQL Version
There are several versions of a T-SQL approach that you can find on the internet, but here is one that parses a string based on a delimiter and returns one row per value. The code has been put together to show you how this is done versus finding the most optimal approach for this problem.
Just copy the code below and execute it in a query window.
CLR Version
This can be done either manually or you can do this using Visual Studio. If you deploy from Visual Studio a lot of these steps are simplified.
Step 1 - CLR code
Before we get started the first thing that needs to be done is to enable the CLR on your SQL Server. This can be done by using the SQL Server Surface Area Configuration tool. Refer to this tip CLR String Sort Function in SQL Server 2005 for more information.
Copy and save the VB.Net code below in a file called: C:\fnParseString.vb or whatever you prefer.
Step 2 - Compile CLR Code - (You only need to do this if you are not using Visual Studio to develop and deploy)
In order to use this code, the code has to be compiled first to create a DLL.
The following command is run from a command line to compile the CLR code using the vbc.exe application. This is found in the .NET 2.0 framework directory. This may be different on your server or desktop. Also, this code should be compiled on the machine where the code will run.
So from a command line run the following command:
The code should now be compiled in a file called: C:\fnParseString.dll
Step 3 - Create Assembly and Function - (You only need to do this if you are not using Visual Studio to develop and deploy)
After the code has been compiled you need to create the assembly and the function with SQL Server. To do this, run these commands in the database where you want to create the function.
For the function you will see three components that are referenced CLRFunctions.UserDefinedFunctions .parseStringCLR .
- CLRFunctions - the assembly reference
- UserDefinedFunctions - the class reference in the VB code
- parseStringCLR - the function reference in the VB code
Step 4 - Test It
To test the functions, run the following SELECT statements.
Here is the output from the above queries:
Result set for the first two queries
Result set for the second two queries
Here is another test that has over 1000 delimited items. With this amount of data we can see that the CLR code is faster. Although each time you run this you may get different execution times, in my tests the CLR was always almost three times faster.
SELECT * FROM dbo.fnParseStringTSQL( '980,365,771,404,977,818,474,748,975,884,347,521,396,791,775,848,438,715,492,781,679,912,830,950,788,
387,738,435,799,475,429,415,967,373,721,882,717,708,837,393,740,360,954,990,794,378,327,741,468,516,
832,753,970,420,744,531,761,811,874,504,747,332,809,897,956,368,409,716,968,386,846,441,431,458,418,
961,479,507,505,367,454,523,425,872,804,981,964,328,362,861,927,841,765,423,939,326,766,714,405,344,
72,494,850,955,770,923,926,722,810,867,400,789,871,900,526,513,364,935,512,371,436,384,316,892,875,
988,906,374,895,911,844,798,745,342,319,330,760,983,478,978,783,973,986,868,467,855,853,388,449,773,
801,529,887,948,838,735,839,793,397,518,893,728,440,860,511,994,831,750,833,524,680,883,466,899,907,
375,933,985,942,414,486,905,894,739,462,885,940,357,514,443,749,754,946,947,725,343,473,452,807,931,
790,959,930,898,896,965,483,510,957,322,460,951,996,982,859,448,966,366,713,445,497,491,515,787,915,
743,470,972,932,944,489,485,732,525,758,772,379,806,325,411,976,805,755,395,752,389,958,995,417,902,
4,727,987,936,506,889,925,402,324,731,851,352,464,392,891,345,795,945,803,917,825,482,469,937,840,
434,383,496,488,450,828,377,774,391,706,934,484,522,729,819,842,490,908,422,763,757,826,920,916,350,
922,461,432,463,834,733,530,780,351,815,863,487,876,824,974,370,356,407,821,394,446,724,382,928,742,
465,817,528,778,969,341,372,999,849,711,442,730,428,857,869,993,759,918,406,710,862,949,796,878,919,
843,881,533,971,401,943,444,784,723,509,800,814,426,412,457,476,455,822,477,720,493,910,416,355,764,
410,421,984,782,736,707,776,471,989,456,903,886,317,914,430,802,827,779,880,399,953,459,962,904,519,
726,433,852,769,997,888,439,879,709,756,527,762,734,390,424,941,835,359,2,921,346,864,866,960,1,858,
719,369,532,979,413,358,323,398,534,873,447,321,403,495,348,991,913,823,797,820,816,847,385,865,376,
746,777,520,381,854,829,767,768,481,361,408,718,331,380,877,751,924,792,813,786,963,812,318,363,329,
929,3,535,427,992,909,508,437,938,320,998,419,901,517,349,856,808,480,870,737,785,453,890,952,451,
836,845,712,975,884,347,521,396,791,775,848,438,715,492,781,679,912,830,950,788,387,738,435,799,475,
429,415,967,373,721,882,717,708,837,393,740,360,954,990,794,378,327,741,468,516,832,753,970,420,744,
531,761,811,874,504,747,332,809,897,956,368,409,716,968,386,846,441,431,458,418,961,479,507,505,367,
454,523,425,872,804,981,964,328,362,861,927,841,765,423,939,326,766,714,405,344,472,494,850,955,770,
923,926,722,810,867,400,789,871,900,526,513,364,935,512,371,436,384,316,892,875,988,906,374,895,911,
844,798,745,342,319,330,760,983,478,978,783,973,986,868,467,855,853,388,449,773,801,529,887,948,838,
735,839,793,397,518,893,728,440,860,511,994,831,750,833,524,680,883,466,899,907,375,933,985,942,414,
486,905,894,739,462,885,940,357,514,443,749,754,946,947,725,343,473,452,807,931,790,959,930,898,896,
965,483,510,957,322,460,951,996,982,859,448,966,366,713,445,497,491,515,787,915,743,470,972,932,944,
489,485,732,525,758,772,379,806,325,411,976,805,755,395,752,389,958,995,417,902,4,727,987,936,506,
889,925,402,324,731,851,352,464,392,891,345,795,945,803,917,825,482,469,937,840,434,383,496,488,450,
828,377,774,391,706,934,484,522,729,819,842,490,908,422,763,757,826,920,916,350,922,461,432,463,834,
733,530,780,351,815,863,487,876,824,974,370,356,407,821,394,446,724,382,928,742,465,817,528,778,969,
341,372,999,849,711,442,730,428,857,869,993,759,918,406,710,862,949,796,878,919,843,881,533,971,401,
943,444,784,723,509,800,814,426,412,457,476,455,822,477,720,493,910,416,355,764,410,421,984,782,736,
707,776,471,989,456,903,886,317,914,430,802,827,779,880,399,953,459,962,904,519,726,433,852,769,997,
888,439,879,709,756,527,762,734,390,424,941,835,359,2,921,346,864,866,960,1,858,719,369,532,979,413,
358,323,398,534,873,447,321,403,495,348,991,913,823,797,820,816,847,385,865,376,746,777,520,381,854,
829,767,768,481,361,408,718,331,380,877,751,924,792,813,786,963,812,318,363,329,929,3,535,427,992,
909,508,437,938,320,998,419,901,517,349,856,808,480,870,737,785,453,890,952,451,836,845,712' ,',')
387,738,435,799,475,429,415,967,373,721,882,717,708,837,393,740,360,954,990,794,378,327,741,468,516,
832,753,970,420,744,531,761,811,874,504,747,332,809,897,956,368,409,716,968,386,846,441,431,458,418,
961,479,507,505,367,454,523,425,872,804,981,964,328,362,861,927,841,765,423,939,326,766,714,405,344,
72,494,850,955,770,923,926,722,810,867,400,789,871,900,526,513,364,935,512,371,436,384,316,892,875,
988,906,374,895,911,844,798,745,342,319,330,760,983,478,978,783,973,986,868,467,855,853,388,449,773,
801,529,887,948,838,735,839,793,397,518,893,728,440,860,511,994,831,750,833,524,680,883,466,899,907,
375,933,985,942,414,486,905,894,739,462,885,940,357,514,443,749,754,946,947,725,343,473,452,807,931,
790,959,930,898,896,965,483,510,957,322,460,951,996,982,859,448,966,366,713,445,497,491,515,787,915,
743,470,972,932,944,489,485,732,525,758,772,379,806,325,411,976,805,755,395,752,389,958,995,417,902,
4,727,987,936,506,889,925,402,324,731,851,352,464,392,891,345,795,945,803,917,825,482,469,937,840,
434,383,496,488,450,828,377,774,391,706,934,484,522,729,819,842,490,908,422,763,757,826,920,916,350,
922,461,432,463,834,733,530,780,351,815,863,487,876,824,974,370,356,407,821,394,446,724,382,928,742,
465,817,528,778,969,341,372,999,849,711,442,730,428,857,869,993,759,918,406,710,862,949,796,878,919,
843,881,533,971,401,943,444,784,723,509,800,814,426,412,457,476,455,822,477,720,493,910,416,355,764,
410,421,984,782,736,707,776,471,989,456,903,886,317,914,430,802,827,779,880,399,953,459,962,904,519,
726,433,852,769,997,888,439,879,709,756,527,762,734,390,424,941,835,359,2,921,346,864,866,960,1,858,
719,369,532,979,413,358,323,398,534,873,447,321,403,495,348,991,913,823,797,820,816,847,385,865,376,
746,777,520,381,854,829,767,768,481,361,408,718,331,380,877,751,924,792,813,786,963,812,318,363,329,
929,3,535,427,992,909,508,437,938,320,998,419,901,517,349,856,808,480,870,737,785,453,890,952,451,
836,845,712,975,884,347,521,396,791,775,848,438,715,492,781,679,912,830,950,788,387,738,435,799,475,
429,415,967,373,721,882,717,708,837,393,740,360,954,990,794,378,327,741,468,516,832,753,970,420,744,
531,761,811,874,504,747,332,809,897,956,368,409,716,968,386,846,441,431,458,418,961,479,507,505,367,
454,523,425,872,804,981,964,328,362,861,927,841,765,423,939,326,766,714,405,344,472,494,850,955,770,
923,926,722,810,867,400,789,871,900,526,513,364,935,512,371,436,384,316,892,875,988,906,374,895,911,
844,798,745,342,319,330,760,983,478,978,783,973,986,868,467,855,853,388,449,773,801,529,887,948,838,
735,839,793,397,518,893,728,440,860,511,994,831,750,833,524,680,883,466,899,907,375,933,985,942,414,
486,905,894,739,462,885,940,357,514,443,749,754,946,947,725,343,473,452,807,931,790,959,930,898,896,
965,483,510,957,322,460,951,996,982,859,448,966,366,713,445,497,491,515,787,915,743,470,972,932,944,
489,485,732,525,758,772,379,806,325,411,976,805,755,395,752,389,958,995,417,902,4,727,987,936,506,
889,925,402,324,731,851,352,464,392,891,345,795,945,803,917,825,482,469,937,840,434,383,496,488,450,
828,377,774,391,706,934,484,522,729,819,842,490,908,422,763,757,826,920,916,350,922,461,432,463,834,
733,530,780,351,815,863,487,876,824,974,370,356,407,821,394,446,724,382,928,742,465,817,528,778,969,
341,372,999,849,711,442,730,428,857,869,993,759,918,406,710,862,949,796,878,919,843,881,533,971,401,
943,444,784,723,509,800,814,426,412,457,476,455,822,477,720,493,910,416,355,764,410,421,984,782,736,
707,776,471,989,456,903,886,317,914,430,802,827,779,880,399,953,459,962,904,519,726,433,852,769,997,
888,439,879,709,756,527,762,734,390,424,941,835,359,2,921,346,864,866,960,1,858,719,369,532,979,413,
358,323,398,534,873,447,321,403,495,348,991,913,823,797,820,816,847,385,865,376,746,777,520,381,854,
829,767,768,481,361,408,718,331,380,877,751,924,792,813,786,963,812,318,363,329,929,3,535,427,992,
909,508,437,938,320,998,419,901,517,349,856,808,480,870,737,785,453,890,952,451,836,845,712' ,',')
SELECT * FROM dbo.fnParseStringCLR( '980,365,771,404,977,818,474,748,975,884,347,521,396,791,775,848,438,715,492,781,679,912,830,950,788,
387,738,435,799,475,429,415,967,373,721,882,717,708,837,393,740,360,954,990,794,378,327,741,468,516,
832,753,970,420,744,531,761,811,874,504,747,332,809,897,956,368,409,716,968,386,846,441,431,458,418,
961,479,507,505,367,454,523,425,872,804,981,964,328,362,861,927,841,765,423,939,326,766,714,405,344,
72,494,850,955,770,923,926,722,810,867,400,789,871,900,526,513,364,935,512,371,436,384,316,892,875,
988,906,374,895,911,844,798,745,342,319,330,760,983,478,978,783,973,986,868,467,855,853,388,449,773,
801,529,887,948,838,735,839,793,397,518,893,728,440,860,511,994,831,750,833,524,680,883,466,899,907,
375,933,985,942,414,486,905,894,739,462,885,940,357,514,443,749,754,946,947,725,343,473,452,807,931,
790,959,930,898,896,965,483,510,957,322,460,951,996,982,859,448,966,366,713,445,497,491,515,787,915,
743,470,972,932,944,489,485,732,525,758,772,379,806,325,411,976,805,755,395,752,389,958,995,417,902,
4,727,987,936,506,889,925,402,324,731,851,352,464,392,891,345,795,945,803,917,825,482,469,937,840,
434,383,496,488,450,828,377,774,391,706,934,484,522,729,819,842,490,908,422,763,757,826,920,916,350,
922,461,432,463,834,733,530,780,351,815,863,487,876,824,974,370,356,407,821,394,446,724,382,928,742,
465,817,528,778,969,341,372,999,849,711,442,730,428,857,869,993,759,918,406,710,862,949,796,878,919,
843,881,533,971,401,943,444,784,723,509,800,814,426,412,457,476,455,822,477,720,493,910,416,355,764,
410,421,984,782,736,707,776,471,989,456,903,886,317,914,430,802,827,779,880,399,953,459,962,904,519,
726,433,852,769,997,888,439,879,709,756,527,762,734,390,424,941,835,359,2,921,346,864,866,960,1,858,
719,369,532,979,413,358,323,398,534,873,447,321,403,495,348,991,913,823,797,820,816,847,385,865,376,
746,777,520,381,854,829,767,768,481,361,408,718,331,380,877,751,924,792,813,786,963,812,318,363,329,
929,3,535,427,992,909,508,437,938,320,998,419,901,517,349,856,808,480,870,737,785,453,890,952,451,
836,845,712,975,884,347,521,396,791,775,848,438,715,492,781,679,912,830,950,788,387,738,435,799,475,
429,415,967,373,721,882,717,708,837,393,740,360,954,990,794,378,327,741,468,516,832,753,970,420,744,
531,761,811,874,504,747,332,809,897,956,368,409,716,968,386,846,441,431,458,418,961,479,507,505,367,
454,523,425,872,804,981,964,328,362,861,927,841,765,423,939,326,766,714,405,344,472,494,850,955,770,
923,926,722,810,867,400,789,871,900,526,513,364,935,512,371,436,384,316,892,875,988,906,374,895,911,
844,798,745,342,319,330,760,983,478,978,783,973,986,868,467,855,853,388,449,773,801,529,887,948,838,
735,839,793,397,518,893,728,440,860,511,994,831,750,833,524,680,883,466,899,907,375,933,985,942,414,
486,905,894,739,462,885,940,357,514,443,749,754,946,947,725,343,473,452,807,931,790,959,930,898,896,
965,483,510,957,322,460,951,996,982,859,448,966,366,713,445,497,491,515,787,915,743,470,972,932,944,
489,485,732,525,758,772,379,806,325,411,976,805,755,395,752,389,958,995,417,902,4,727,987,936,506,
889,925,402,324,731,851,352,464,392,891,345,795,945,803,917,825,482,469,937,840,434,383,496,488,450,
828,377,774,391,706,934,484,522,729,819,842,490,908,422,763,757,826,920,916,350,922,461,432,463,834,
733,530,780,351,815,863,487,876,824,974,370,356,407,821,394,446,724,382,928,742,465,817,528,778,969,
341,372,999,849,711,442,730,428,857,869,993,759,918,406,710,862,949,796,878,919,843,881,533,971,401,
943,444,784,723,509,800,814,426,412,457,476,455,822,477,720,493,910,416,355,764,410,421,984,782,736,
707,776,471,989,456,903,886,317,914,430,802,827,779,880,399,953,459,962,904,519,726,433,852,769,997,
888,439,879,709,756,527,762,734,390,424,941,835,359,2,921,346,864,866,960,1,858,719,369,532,979,413,
358,323,398,534,873,447,321,403,495,348,991,913,823,797,820,816,847,385,865,376,746,777,520,381,854,
829,767,768,481,361,408,718,331,380,877,751,924,792,813,786,963,812,318,363,329,929,3,535,427,992,
909,508,437,938,320,998,419,901,517,349,856,808,480,870,737,785,453,890,952,451,836,845,712' ,',')
387,738,435,799,475,429,415,967,373,721,882,717,708,837,393,740,360,954,990,794,378,327,741,468,516,
832,753,970,420,744,531,761,811,874,504,747,332,809,897,956,368,409,716,968,386,846,441,431,458,418,
961,479,507,505,367,454,523,425,872,804,981,964,328,362,861,927,841,765,423,939,326,766,714,405,344,
72,494,850,955,770,923,926,722,810,867,400,789,871,900,526,513,364,935,512,371,436,384,316,892,875,
988,906,374,895,911,844,798,745,342,319,330,760,983,478,978,783,973,986,868,467,855,853,388,449,773,
801,529,887,948,838,735,839,793,397,518,893,728,440,860,511,994,831,750,833,524,680,883,466,899,907,
375,933,985,942,414,486,905,894,739,462,885,940,357,514,443,749,754,946,947,725,343,473,452,807,931,
790,959,930,898,896,965,483,510,957,322,460,951,996,982,859,448,966,366,713,445,497,491,515,787,915,
743,470,972,932,944,489,485,732,525,758,772,379,806,325,411,976,805,755,395,752,389,958,995,417,902,
4,727,987,936,506,889,925,402,324,731,851,352,464,392,891,345,795,945,803,917,825,482,469,937,840,
434,383,496,488,450,828,377,774,391,706,934,484,522,729,819,842,490,908,422,763,757,826,920,916,350,
922,461,432,463,834,733,530,780,351,815,863,487,876,824,974,370,356,407,821,394,446,724,382,928,742,
465,817,528,778,969,341,372,999,849,711,442,730,428,857,869,993,759,918,406,710,862,949,796,878,919,
843,881,533,971,401,943,444,784,723,509,800,814,426,412,457,476,455,822,477,720,493,910,416,355,764,
410,421,984,782,736,707,776,471,989,456,903,886,317,914,430,802,827,779,880,399,953,459,962,904,519,
726,433,852,769,997,888,439,879,709,756,527,762,734,390,424,941,835,359,2,921,346,864,866,960,1,858,
719,369,532,979,413,358,323,398,534,873,447,321,403,495,348,991,913,823,797,820,816,847,385,865,376,
746,777,520,381,854,829,767,768,481,361,408,718,331,380,877,751,924,792,813,786,963,812,318,363,329,
929,3,535,427,992,909,508,437,938,320,998,419,901,517,349,856,808,480,870,737,785,453,890,952,451,
836,845,712,975,884,347,521,396,791,775,848,438,715,492,781,679,912,830,950,788,387,738,435,799,475,
429,415,967,373,721,882,717,708,837,393,740,360,954,990,794,378,327,741,468,516,832,753,970,420,744,
531,761,811,874,504,747,332,809,897,956,368,409,716,968,386,846,441,431,458,418,961,479,507,505,367,
454,523,425,872,804,981,964,328,362,861,927,841,765,423,939,326,766,714,405,344,472,494,850,955,770,
923,926,722,810,867,400,789,871,900,526,513,364,935,512,371,436,384,316,892,875,988,906,374,895,911,
844,798,745,342,319,330,760,983,478,978,783,973,986,868,467,855,853,388,449,773,801,529,887,948,838,
735,839,793,397,518,893,728,440,860,511,994,831,750,833,524,680,883,466,899,907,375,933,985,942,414,
486,905,894,739,462,885,940,357,514,443,749,754,946,947,725,343,473,452,807,931,790,959,930,898,896,
965,483,510,957,322,460,951,996,982,859,448,966,366,713,445,497,491,515,787,915,743,470,972,932,944,
489,485,732,525,758,772,379,806,325,411,976,805,755,395,752,389,958,995,417,902,4,727,987,936,506,
889,925,402,324,731,851,352,464,392,891,345,795,945,803,917,825,482,469,937,840,434,383,496,488,450,
828,377,774,391,706,934,484,522,729,819,842,490,908,422,763,757,826,920,916,350,922,461,432,463,834,
733,530,780,351,815,863,487,876,824,974,370,356,407,821,394,446,724,382,928,742,465,817,528,778,969,
341,372,999,849,711,442,730,428,857,869,993,759,918,406,710,862,949,796,878,919,843,881,533,971,401,
943,444,784,723,509,800,814,426,412,457,476,455,822,477,720,493,910,416,355,764,410,421,984,782,736,
707,776,471,989,456,903,886,317,914,430,802,827,779,880,399,953,459,962,904,519,726,433,852,769,997,
888,439,879,709,756,527,762,734,390,424,941,835,359,2,921,346,864,866,960,1,858,719,369,532,979,413,
358,323,398,534,873,447,321,403,495,348,991,913,823,797,820,816,847,385,865,376,746,777,520,381,854,
829,767,768,481,361,408,718,331,380,877,751,924,792,813,786,963,812,318,363,329,929,3,535,427,992,
909,508,437,938,320,998,419,901,517,349,856,808,480,870,737,785,453,890,952,451,836,845,712' ,',')
Using the functions against data in a table
A reader asked how these functions can be used against data that exists in a table. Here is a simple example of populating a table and then using these functions:
SummaryWith the above you can see the two different approaches to tackling this issue. For the most part you are probably fine with either code set, but do some testing to see which approach works best.
Source cocollected from mssqltips.com
No comments :
Post a Comment